I don't have as much chicken experience as most of you, so I am not a good judge. I can tell you I had a RR rooster that used to attack my mom and dad, and went after my brother and sister a couple of times-he never went after me. But, they were free range chickens, and if the family carried a broom, even a small broom, the rooster left them alone. My dad finally took off his belt to defend himself from the rooster, and it wound around the roosters neck and killed him. That rooster was defending his girls and his territory, and he did a great job at that, even protecting against our Collies. Once he was gone, my hens started disappearing a couple each week until I had -0- chickens left.